Multiple Car Insurance Policies: Can You Have Two on One Vehicle?

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

If you own multiple vehicles, you may be wondering if it’s possible to have two car insurance policies for the same car. While it is technically possible, there are several factors to consider before doing so.

Multiple Car Insurance Policies: Can You Have Two on One Vehicle?Multiple Car Insurance Policies: Can You Have Two on One Vehicle?

Why would someone want two car insurance policies for one vehicle?

Having two car insurance policies on one vehicle may seem redundant, but there are a few scenarios where it might make sense:

  • Primary and secondary drivers: If the primary driver of a vehicle has high insurance rates due to their driving history or age, adding a secondary driver with a clean record could lower overall premiums.
  • Additional coverage: Depending on the specific policy coverage, having additional protection from another provider could help fill gaps in areas such as liability or collision coverage.
  • Commercial and personal use: If a vehicle is used both for personal reasons and business purposes, separate policies may provide better protection in each area.

Potential drawbacks of having multiple car insurance policies

While some situations can benefit from having two auto insurance plans for the same automobile, certain issues need consideration:

  • Insurance fraud: Having dual auto-insurance contracts to commit fraud isn’t legal. This includes trying to get more money by filing claims using different companies.
  • Overlap: Some aspects of split-protection plans functionality can overlap—like roadside assistance– which leaves consumers with overlapping fees that aren’t actually providing any extra benefits.
  • Complexity: Managing multiple car insurances can lead occasional confusion when dealing with customer service regarding making payments or submitting claims.

So Is It Possible To Have Two Car Insurance Policies For One Car?

The short answer is yes; however, most insurers won’t allow this practice under typical circumstances. Nearly every regular auto insurer prohibits carrying more than one plan covering identical damages because insurers fear that customers will attempt to double-dip should they submit duplicate claims.

Negotiating two policies for identical coverage isn’t feasible or seen as a reasonable plan because of worries about both double-dipping and increased potential fraud from unscrupulous people who may file more than one insurance claim.

Bottom Line

Having two car insurance plans will not benefit the policyholder unless there is some unique situation, like having personal coverage and commercial coverage on the same vehicle. Otherwise, customers should avoid pursuing it to prevent outlays for redundant services. If you’re looking to save money on auto-insurance there are other solutions worth considering that can lower rates without raising red flags.

By following these tips when shopping around for your next auto-insurance quote, you’ll be able to compare quotes easily while ensuring that you have adequate protection in place:

  • Review different auto insurers’ discounts offerings
  • Consider increasing your deductible amounts
  • Talk with an agent or broker about bundling home/auto insurance policies

Remember, safety is critical! Make sure that whichever insurer you choose provides proper protection at affordable prices so that you can drive confidently knowing that everything’s taken care of.


Here are three popular FAQs on having multiple car insurance policies for one vehicle:

Q1. Can you have two car insurance policies for the same vehicle?

A1: Technically, it’s not illegal to have two insurance policies on the same vehicle but it is unnecessary because both companies will not pay out a claim. Having more than one policy does not increase the amount of payout in case of an accident.

Q2: Why would someone consider having multiple car insurance policies for one vehicle?

A2: Someone might consider having multiple car insurance policies if they’re trying to obtain extra coverage or benefits that their primary policy might lack, such as gap coverage or roadside assistance services.

Q3: What should I do if I accidentally have two active car insurance policies at once?

A3: If you unintentionally find yourself with two active car insurance policies on your vehicle, you must contact both insurers immediately and inform them of the situation. The excess payments made towards your premium from neither company will be refunded back to you so ensure this doesn’t happen by eliminating any double-insurance confusion between providers before selecting a provider for auto-insurance-service